Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

Latest post Sun, Oct 4 2009 5:44 PM by Kate Case, RESA, ASHSR, Home Stager. 11 replies.
  • Sat, May 16 2009 2:40 PM

    Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Below is a response to an article I read in Realty Times: http://realtytimes.com/rtpages/20081231_inout.htm . (Basically, in the article, the author says that staging is OUT in 2009. As you can imagine, I have a differing opinion and was shocked that an “expert” of his status would say such a thing.) I was glad he published this article though, as it gave me the opportunity to respond.

     

    - Ashley

     

    ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
    Hi Mark,
     
    I just read your article “What's In, What's Out with Home Buyers in 2009?”    I was surprised to see that an author of several books on selling real estate and niche marketing and someone who is viewed as a real estate expert would not advocate a tried and true marketing principle of taking a productand making it better, which increases its value and sale-ability.
     
    I’ve worked in real estate for over a decade. As a new home sales representative and licensed realtor, I recognized the importance of making the properties I was selling stand out among the rest. It’s not rocket science, just basic marketing principles.  I’ve sold millions in real estate and worked with hundreds of buyers.  I know what sends them running and I know what compels them to make an offer. This same principle is why builders spend large portions of their marketing budgets on decorating their model homes and why they use the models as a very effective marketing tool. Malcolm Gladwell even wrote an entire book on the principle Blink.  His book is about rapid cognition, about the kind of thinking that happens in a blink of an eye. When you meet someone for the first time, or walk into a house you are thinking of buying, or read the first few sentences of a book, your mind takes about two seconds to jump to a series of conclusions.  Gary Keller even dedicates an entire chapter to the subject of home staging in his latest book, Shift: How Top Real Estate Agents Tackle Tough Times. In it, he says, “A seller should never ask if they should stage. This is simply the wrong type of thinking and the wrong question. The question they should ask is how should I stage? Staging is an essential part of the marketing process.”
     
    I’m surprised that you would diminish the importance of such an effective marketing tool that is recognized across all industries, not just real estate. Below is an example of effective marketing in a completely unrelated industry. Here, the competing companies have take two similar products, and packaged them very differently. Which one looks more appealing? Which one stimulates a positive emotional response? Which one seems like a vacation in a bottle and which one conjures of images of living in a trailer park? (Not that there’s anything wrong with that – my family and I are RV enthusiast, but I think you get my point.)
     
     
    If you’re referring to the minority of inexperienced or ineffective home stagers or agents who place bad silk floral arrangements and a few plants in a home and think that’s going to sell it, then that’s understandable that you would not advocate that as an effective marketing tool, however, I’m surprised you would write about the minority in your article.  True home staging is much more pervasive than “tired silk plants” and “stale potpourri”. It’s the process of assessing all aspects of the property and figuring out a way to make that property stand out and look better than the competition. It’s the process of creating value on a small budget and finding areas of improvement that yield a return on the investment that justifies the investment in the first place.
     
    Mark, I’m not usually the type to respond to articles or write “letters to the editor”.  I’m far too busy and I believe that everyone deserves to have their own opinion, however, in this case, I feel that you have the opportunity to educate professionals with your article, and you’re doing the opposite and perhaps misinforming them.
     
    I’m passionate about this not because one of the companies I own offers home staging as part of our services, but because I see what a difference effective home staging has made in many peoples’ lives. Most recently, our company staged a vacant property in a community with a 12-month supply of inventory. The owner had just been laid off and desperately needed to sell. The combination of an effective pricing strategy and a cost-effective staging plan created a property that stood out among the sea of other listings, and it sold in less than 2 weeks after being on the market. We have many more stories like this one.
     
    One of the things that I love about what we do is that we don’t just have a job. We do work that helps people who desperately need it in times like these. We make a difference in peoples’ lives. We, along with their Realtors, help them to avoid foreclosure, bankruptcy, stress and turmoil.  We help Realtors by assisting them to sell their listings, and by highlighting their true level of professionalism and expertise, which shines through every time they sell a listing more quickly than the other agents in town. This helps further their careers and ours.
     
    As I say in the Texas Real Estate Commission-approved MCE course I teach for Realtors on Strategic Marketing through Home Staging, an agent isn’t doing their job if they don’t help their sellers to effectively prepare their listings to go on the market. They are paid because they are experts and professionals. Part of their marketing plan should include the effective preparation of the home as a product. Some call it Home Staging, I call it Marketing 101.  Whatever you call it, I often draw the analogy of my job as a parent to the job of a listing agent – when my 6 year old son says he doesn’t feel like brushing his teeth or doing his school work, I wouldn’t be doing my job as a parent if I just said, “OK!” and let him off the hook. It’s my job to discipline my child. The root of the word discipline is to teach. I’m the expert – I’m older, wiser and have seen the consequences of poor dental hygiene or lazy school work habits.  The same holds true for Realtors as it applies to marketing real estate.
     
    Thank you for your time, and for writing an otherwise interesting read! J
     
     
    Yours truly,
      
     
    Ashley Whittenberger

    www.theinterioritycomplex.com

    "Creating a beautiful space shouldn't break the bank, or the environment."

    www.theinterioritycomplexuniversity.com

    "Uncommon and highly effective resources to grow your design business."

  • Fri, May 22 2009 11:30 AM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Hi Ashley,

    That was a very well written and informative response!  I love your idea that "staging" is really just a new way of saying "marketing".  That is exactly what it is.  Any realtor that doesn't use staging for their listings is doing their clients a disservice.  I am suprised at how many realtors approach me for staging only because their clients asked them to - how backwards!

    Great job!

  • Sun, May 24 2009 1:35 PM In reply to

    • maryjnowak
    • Top 150 Contributor
    • Joined on Thu, Apr 16 2009
    • Posts 4
    • Points 4,000

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Fabulous Ashley...just absolutely fabulous!!!  I can't wait to hear his response:)

    ~Mary

  • Tue, May 26 2009 8:08 AM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Excellent letter Ashley! Thank you for taking the time to write and post it here. Marketing 101 is right! Home Staging is marketing for most people's largest investment, their home and they deserve to get what it's worth.

    Please post the reply if you get one.


    "There is never a second chance to make a first impression"

    Selling a home in North Texas? Let us help you make your Home the Star attraction in the competitive real estate market!  Home Star Staging is here for you Texas!

    phone: 469-964-0516

    email: karen@homestarstaging.com

    website: www.homestarstaging.com

     

  • Thu, May 28 2009 7:40 PM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Ashley, 

    Great response. I'm not sure what the author was thinking. I've been in the industry staging homes since 1995, before anyone in Dallas knew what "staging" was. All the real estate agents knew was whatever I was doing WORKED! I spent today staging a house for one of our local news outlets because even the media realize that staging WORKS.

     A house I recently staged had a contract in three days while the property that was not staged, across the street, has been on the market for a year!

    In the present economy staging gives a seller the BEST return on investment they can possibly make. Buyers today want to walk into a beautiful house, period. Staging works and in a recession it is really foolish not to utilize this tool.

    Reality check: Staging Works!

    Karen Eubank

     

    Redefining Your Home

    Karen Eubank

    Eubank Staging www.eubankstaging.com

    RESA

  • Thu, Jul 2 2009 7:23 AM In reply to

    • msl007
    • Top 150 Contributor
    • Joined on Fri, Jun 26 2009
    • Posts 4
    • Points 5,800

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    As a new home stager, I keep hearing comments like this from other stagers and I just heard it from a potential client this past week end.  He has a house that has been on the market for well over a year and his agent told him that he did not need to use a home stager because the house would eventually sell.  I went to the home to do an inspection and give him a quote for my home staging services.  Although the house was new, it needed to have two of the main rooms repainted from a dark charcoal gray to a lighter shade, a broken toilet repaired, and several holes in the walls respackled and painted, along with a thorough cleaning and carpets steamed cleaned.  I told him this needed to be done before staging and that he also needed to take care of the weeds in the flower beds and refresh the mulch, etc. 

    He seemed shocked, but extremely appreciative, that I would even suggest any of this and said his agent told him that home stagers do not know what sells homes or how to sell a home.  I then asked him if he was aware that these potential items could be putting buyers off because they walk in, see a dark  home that has a few repairs needed.  The condition does not match the age of the house and because his house is in a very out of the way location, if it is not in a state prepared to sell - it won't sell as quickly as he would expect.  I then gave him a price quote for the furniture rental on Monday and a quote for my services - his agent has told him he would be wasting his money and so, now he will not committ to either of the contracts! But when his home doesn't sell, I am sure I will hear from him again. 

    My thought is this: home staging is becoming a very lucrative business; I have seen realtors now call themselves stagers, but I doubt if they would go to the extremes to move furniture, organize, store items, make the recommendations that stagers do or even clean houses.  Why aren't they out MARKETING the home?.  My last home sold in less than 8 weeks because of the home staging I did.  The traffic increased over 200%; my client had 3 offers in 6 weeks; the agents don't get paid until the house sells.  Why are these people telling their clients not to use stagers?   In Birmingham where I live, staging is a relatively new concept and I am spending a lot of time marketing to agents in the hopes that they will eventually use us.  They just take the attitude that homes will sell eventually, they don't market them to their fullest potential and certainly do not recommend the homes even need to be clean.  Very perplexing to say the least.

    I told my potential client that staging is an investment in his home equity and certainly better than reducing the price of the home.  He is paying two mortgages but now because of his agent he doesn't feel he should pay to stage his house!

    I wonder how come some agents get it and some don't?

    Lisa Bond

    The Stagehand Home Staging and Redesign Services

       

     

     

  • Thu, Jul 2 2009 8:20 AM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Great story, Lisa. It exemplifies exactly what I'm talking about. I hope the client you met will see the light and understand they need to package their product. In the meantime, I suppose we can all just keep doing our best to educate realtors and sellers on the benefits of staging!

    www.theinterioritycomplex.com

    "Creating a beautiful space shouldn't break the bank, or the environment."

    www.theinterioritycomplexuniversity.com

    "Uncommon and highly effective resources to grow your design business."

  • Thu, Jul 2 2009 1:03 PM In reply to

    • Dan Eason
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on Tue, Apr 1 2008
    • San Antonio
    • Posts 213
    • Points 351,100

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Great letter and examples here.  Ashley, I especially like your picture example.  Staging really is about better marketing.  Think of all the products we buy on a daily basis that have competitors with very similar products.  We choose the product we buy, a lot of times subconsciously, because of marketing.  In most cases, the difference in products is simply the difference in perception the buyer has.  In my opinion, home staging helps improve the home buyer's perception of the home, even subtly.  The buyer may not be able to pinpoint why one clean and decluttered home with similar features is better than the other, they just know they feel better being in the professionally staged home.  

    Advertising is a multi-billion dollar business because products have to be differentiated from the competition.  Home staging is successful because a staged home is an effectively differentiated home.

     

  • Wed, Aug 26 2009 9:54 AM In reply to

    • Holly1204
    • Top 500 Contributor
    • Joined on Wed, Aug 26 2009
    • Posts 2
    • Points 3,800

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Ashley,

    Would you mind if I quoted your well written response on my web site? It is a great peice on staging that many people need to read.  Thanks!

     

    Holly Dixon

    http://timelessinteriorshiltonhead.com

  • Wed, Aug 26 2009 5:58 PM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Holly,

    No problem! I would love it if you could include a link to our website somewhere, as we're always trying to increase our inbound linking!!


    Thanks!

    www.theinterioritycomplex.com

    "Creating a beautiful space shouldn't break the bank, or the environment."

    www.theinterioritycomplexuniversity.com

    "Uncommon and highly effective resources to grow your design business."

  • Fri, Aug 28 2009 6:07 PM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    Hi Ashley and everyone,

    I couldn't agree more!  I live outside LA, and although some consider anywhere near LA as an often "trendsetting" area, I don't think you would realize that with the lack of knowledge many of our agents have about the benefts of properly staging a home! It becomes such a frustration to tell them over and over again, and have them "just not get it"!! 

    As a staging instructor myself, I think it all begins with proper EDUCATION...especially of agents.  They are the "front line offensive" to educating their clients, so we can get in there and do our jobs! You would think with all the info available on the internet, magazines, television and materials delivered directly to the agents' in-boxes, they would ALL have embraced the concept and benefits of staging their properties. Not so in my experience. 

     What saddens me the most is the "dis-service" they are providing their clents....the example given of the charcoal paint, holes in walls, and raggedy plantings reinforces that point. As professional stagers, we ALL have an obligation to EDUCATE, not only homeowners, but agents as well! 

    Thanks for letting me "vent" a bit!  I will never give up touting the marketing value of a "good" home staging. It should be our goal to have staging be thought of as a mandatory part of selling a home.. Cheers to our ultimate goal!!!

    Marcia Smart

    Smart Interior Styling

    www.SmartRedesign.com

    www.RedesignTraining.com

     

    Author of:Decorating by Instinct

    www.smartredesign.com/book.html 

    Creator of:"Redesign Like A Pro" DVD

    http://www.smartredesign.com/RedesignLikeaPro.htm

     

    Author of: Accessorizing With Style

    Contributor:IRIS in the House -National Book Awardswinner

    www.smartredesign.com/decoratingbooks.html

     

     

     

    Author of: Accessorizing With Style

    Co-author of:IRIS in the House -National Book Awards winner

    Contributor to: 301 Simple Things You Can Do to Sell Your Home Now...www.smartredesign.com/decoratingbooks.html

  • Sun, Oct 4 2009 5:44 PM In reply to

    Re: Staging is out? Really? What next... the Law of Gravity won't apply?

    I am so glad you decided to replay to this author, as professional home stagers we have enough to overcome and really do not need to have bad press telling Realtors they should not be using us.  As a new business, the majority of my business comes from home sellers calling me directly  and I am working only with them. I think there is a reluctance with Realtors to use home stagers in my area or they feel they will "stage" the property themselves.  

Page 1 of 1 (12 items) | RSS